%ents; ]>
Personal Eventing via Pubsub This document specifies XMPP semantics for using the publish-subscribe protocol to broadcast state change events associated with an instant messaging and presence account. &LEGALNOTICE; 0163 Draft Standards Track Standards JIG Council XMPP Core XMPP IM XEP-0030 XEP-0060 XEP-0115 pep &stpeter; &ksmith; 1.1pre1 in progress, last updated 2007-04-03 psa

Defined atomic publish+configure action for use on first publish; added friendly but non-normative How It Works section to introduction; tightened up definition of normative sections; explicitly defined auto-create and publish-and-configure features.

1.0 2006-09-20 psa

Per a vote of the Jabber Council, advanced status to Draft.

0.15 2006-08-30 psa

Added the deliver_notifications and send_last_published_item configuration options to the recommended defaults.

0.14 2006-08-02 psa

Changed various recommended defaults from SHOULD to MUST; corrected several errors in the text and examples.

0.13 2006-08-01 psa

Recommended node creation with default configuration on initial publish; corrected several errors and clarified several points in the text.

0.12 2006-08-01 psa

Simplified the subscription process using XMPP presence and entity capabilities.

0.11 2006-07-20 psa

Clarified rules regarding number of notifications and when to generate notifications; corrected several errors in the text and examples.

0.10 2006-07-07 psa

Updated to reflect version 1.8 of XEP-0060.

0.9 2006-06-15 psa

Updated to reflect use of data forms in XEP-0060.

0.8 2006-04-10 psa

Clarified terminology and defaults.

0.7 2006-04-10 psa

Specified that notifications are to be sent from bare JID, not full JID.

0.6 2006-04-10 psa

Updated to reflect pubsub changes; clarified business rules for generation of notifications and cancellation of subscriptions.

0.5 2006-03-09 psa

Modified roster groups example to use jabber:x:data; added note about advertising client support for PEP.

0.4 2006-02-02 psa/ks

Specified rules for generation of notifications, including use of presence in determining address of intended recipient for notifications and sending of last published item on receipt of presence information; changed name to Personal Eventing Protocol; specified service discovery identity of pubsub/pep; removed section on service types; added Kevin Smith as co-author.

0.3 2006-01-30 psa

Specified that a service may enforce additional privacy and security policies; specified that an account owner must always be allowed to subscribe and to retrieve items; specified that an implementation should enforce access modifications resulting from roster state changes.

0.2 2006-01-11 psa

Updated to reflect proposed XEP-0060 modifications.

0.1 2005-11-02 psa

Initial version.

0.0.2 2005-10-25 psa

Added more details and examples.

0.0.1 2005-10-24 psa

First draft.

Personal eventing provides a way for a Jabber/XMPP user to send updates or "events" to other users, who are typically contacts in the user's roster. An event can be anything that a user wants to make known to other people, such as those described in &xep0080;, &xep0107;, &xep0108;, and &xep0118;. While the XMPP &xep0060; extension ("pubsub") can be used to broadcast such events associated, the full pubsub protocol is often thought of as complicated and therefore has not been widely implemented. Instead, many "extended presence" formats are currently sent using the &PRESENCE; stanza type; unfortunately, this overloads presence, results in unnecessary presence traffic, and does not provide fine-grained control over access. The use of publish-subscribe rather than presence is therefore preferable. To make publish-subscribe functionality more accessible (especially to instant messaging and presence applications that conform to &xmppim;), this document defines a simplified subset of pubsub that can be followed by instant messaging client and server developers to more easily deploy personal eventing services across the Jabber/XMPP network. We label this subset "Personal Eventing via Pubsub" or PEP. This document does not show error flows related to the various publish-subscribe use cases referenced herein, since they are exhaustively defined in XEP-0060. The reader is referred to XEP-0060 for all relevant protocol details related to the XMPP publish-subscribe extension.

This section provides a friendly, non-normative introduction to the workings of personal eventing via pubsub (PEP).

There are two sides to personal eventing: what the user does to generate events and what the contact does to receive events. As shown in the following examples, both are simplified in PEP as compared to generic pubsub.

Imagine that you are a Shakespearean character named Juliet and that you want to generate the following kinds of events that may be of interest to other people:

  1. Information about what music you're listening to, which anyone may see even if they are not allowed to know your online/offline presence (i.e., a pubsub access model of "presence")
  2. Information about your geographical location, which only contacts in your "Friends" roster group may see (i.e., a pubsub access model of "roster" with a group of "Friends")

We assume that there are three other users who have the following relationship to you:

  1. benvolio@montague.net, who has no subscription to your presence
  2. nurse@capulet.com, who has a bidirectional subscription to your presence and who is in your "Servants" roster group
  3. romeo@montague.net, who has a bidirectional subscription to your presence and who is in your "Friends" roster group

We also assume that your server (montague.net) supports PEP and that your client discovered that support when you logged in.

Now you start playing a song on your music playing software. Your client captures that "event" and publishes it to your server:

Gerald Finzi Introduction (Allegro vigoroso) Music for "Love's Labors Lost" (Suite for small orchestra) 1 255 http://jabber.org/protocol/pubsub#node_config presence ]]>

Note the following about your publish request:

  1. It is sent with no 'to' address (see Every Account a Pubsub Service).
  2. It specifies a node of "http://jabber.org/protocol/tune" (see One Node per Namespace).
  3. It includes the desired node configuration, which here is a presence access model (see Fire and Forget).

If all goes well (see Publishing Events), everyone who is interested in what you are listening to will receive notification of the event:

Gerald Finzi Introduction (Allegro vigoroso) Music for "Love's Labors Lost" (Suite for small orchestra) 1 255 Gerald Finzi Introduction (Allegro vigoroso) Music for "Love's Labors Lost" (Suite for small orchestra) 1 255 ]]>

But how do Romeo and the Nurse tell your server that they are interested in knowing what you're listening to? In generic pubsub they need to explicitly subscribe to your "http://jabber.org/protocol/tune" node. That is still necessary for open access model nodes in PEP if another user does not have a subscription to your presence, such as benvolio@montague.net in our scenario. In PEP, they only need to advertise that they are interested by including some special flags (see Filtered Notifications) in the &xep0115; information they include in their presence broadcasts (see Use Presence).

]]>

Your server knows to send tune information to Romeo not directly because his client advertises an 'ext' value of "sendmetunes" (the 'ext' values have no semantic meaning in XEP-0115) but because the disco#info response from the "http://www.chatopus.com/ec#sendmetunes" node advertises a feature of "http://jabber.org/protocol/tune+notify", where the "+notify" suffix indicates interest in the protocol that precedes the suffix:

]]>

Naturally your server doesn't need to send out a disco#info request every time, since it will quickly create a large cache of such extensions!

So that's the general idea. We'll demonstrate it again with an example of geolocation...

First your client generates a geolocation event:

Italy 45.44 Venice 12.33 http://jabber.org/protocol/pubsub#node_config roster Friends ]]>

Then your server sends event notifications, this time addressing the event only to Romeo, since the Nurse is not in your Friends roster group:

Italy 45.44 Venice 12.33 ]]>

And your server knows to send the geolocation notification to Romeo because (1) he is in your Friends group and (2) his client advertised interest in "http://jabber.org/protocol/geolocation" events.

Personal eventing via pubsub ("PEP") is based on the following principles:

  1. Every account a pubsub service.
  2. One publisher per node.
  3. One node per namespace.
  4. Use presence.
  5. Filter notifications based on expressed interest.
  6. Smart defaults.
  7. Fire and forget.

These principles are described more fully below.

When a user creates an account (or has an account provisioned) at a Jabber/XMPP server that supports PEP, the server associates a virtual pubsub service with the account. This greatly simplifies the task of discovering the account owner's personal pubsub nodes, since the root pubsub node simply is the account owner's bare JID (&BAREJID;). This assumption also simplifies publishing and subscribing.

There is no need for multiple publishers to a PEP service, since by definition the service generates information associated with only one entity. The owner-publisher for every node is the bare JID of the account owner.

There is only one publish-subscribe node associated with any given payload type (XML namespace) for the account owner (e.g., there is one pubsub node for geolocation events, one node for tune events, and one node for mood events). This simplifies node creation, discovery, publishing, and subscribing.

Although generic publish-subscribe services do not necessarily have access to presence information about subscribers, PEP services are integrated with presence in the following ways:

  • Each messaging and presence account simply is a virtual publish-subscribe service.
  • The default access model is "presence".
  • A contact's subscription to an account owner's personal eventing data is normally handled via the existence of an XMPP presence subscription.
  • Services take account of subscriber presence in the generation of notifications. This works only if the subscription state is "both" (see RFC 3921).

These uses of presence simplify the task of developing compliant clients (cf. &xep0134;).

By default, the existence of an XMPP presence subscription is used to establish a PEP subscription to the account owner's personal eventing data. In order to filter which notifications are sent by the PEP service, the contact's client includes extended &xep0115; information in the presence notifications it sends to the account owner, and the PEP service sends only those notifications that match the contact's expressed notification preferences.

Most pubsub configuration options and metadata are not needed for personal eventing. Instead, PEP services offer smart defaults to simplify node creation and management.

A client should be able to publish an item without having to worry about whether the node exists; if the node does not exist, the server simply creates the node automatically and applies the specified configuration.

An account owner publishes an item to a node by following the protocol specified in XEP-0060:

Gerald Finzi Introduction (Allegro vigoroso) Music for "Love's Labors Lost" (Suite for small orchestra) 1 255 ]]>

If the node does not already exist, the PEP service MUST create the node (see fire and forget). This "auto-create" feature MUST be supported by a PEP service, but support for the feature is OPTIONAL on the part of a generic pubsub service. (Naturally, the account owner's client MAY follow the node creation use case specified in XEP-0060 before attempting to publish an item.)

Because PEP nodes may be automatically created, a client MAY specify the desired node configuration along with the publish request:

Gerald Finzi Introduction (Allegro vigoroso) Music for "Love's Labors Lost" (Suite for small orchestra) 1 255 http://jabber.org/protocol/pubsub#node_config presence ]]>

The PEP service MUST process such a request in accordance with the rules shown in the table below. This "publish-and-configure" feature MUST be supported by a PEP service, but support for the feature is OPTIONAL on the part of a generic pubsub service.

Case Result
The node does not exist and the publish request does not include a <configure/> element. The node is automatically created with default configuration (which for PEP nodes MUST be the presence access model) and the item is published.
The node does not exist and the publish request includes a <configure/> element. The node is automatically created with the specified configuration and the item is published.
The node exists and the publish request does not include a <configure/> element. The item is published and the node configuration is not modified.
The node exists and the publish request includes a <configure/> element. If the specified configuration matches the existing node configuration, the item is published and the node configuration is not modified. If the specified configuration does not match the existing node configuration, the server returns a &conflict; error to the account owner (with an application-specific error of <config-does-not-match/>), the item is not published, and the node configuration is not modified.

If the publication logic dictates that event notifications shall be sent, the account owner's server generates notifications and sends them to all appropriate entities as described in the Receiving Event Notifications section of this document, as well as to any of the account owner's available resources.

An entity shall receive event notifications if:

  1. The node has an open access model and the entity has explicitly discovered and subscribed to the node as explained in XEP-0060.
  2. The entity shares presence with the account owner (see Presence Sharing), is authorized to receive events from the node in accordance with the node access model (see XEP-0060), and advertises an interest in the payload type (see Notification Filtering).

When a contact is affiliated with the account owner through a presence subscription, PEP greatly simplifies the subscription process. This is done by associating the presence subscription with a pubsub subscription to the account owner's root collection node (i.e., bare JID), with a subscription_type of "items" and a subscription_depth of "all".

Consider the following presence subscription exchange:

]]>

For PEP purposes, this is equivalent to the following pubsub subscription exchange:

http://jabber.org/protocol/pubsub#subscribe_options items all ]]>

Note: Automated pubsub subscriptions MUST be based on the JID contained in the 'from' address of the presence subscription request, which for IM contacts will be a bare JID (&BAREJID;).

A contact may not want to receive notifications for all payload types. A contact SHOULD signal its preferences to the account owner's server by including XEP-0115 information that specifies the namespaces for which the contact wishes to receive notifications (if any).

In order to make this possible, all possible payload namespaces can be appended with the string "+notify" to indicate that the contact wishes to receive notifications for the payload format. Thus if Romeo wants to receive notifications for activity data and geolocation data but not tune data, his client would advertise support for the following namespaces in the disco#info results it sends: Including, say, the 'http://jabber.org/protocol/geoloc' namespace indicates that the client understands the geolocation namespace, whereas including the 'http://jabber.org/protocol/geoloc+notify' namespace indicates that the client wishes to receive notifications related to geolocation.

  • http://jabber.org/protocol/geoloc+notify
  • http://jabber.org/protocol/tune+notify

This set of namespaces would then be advertised as a XEP-0115 "ext" value, such as the following:

]]>

Note: In XEP-0115, the "ext" values are opaque strings with no semantic meaning.

It is the responsibility of the account owner's server to cache XEP-0115 information (including "ext" values and their associated namespaces). When the server receives presence from a contact, it MUST check that presence information for entity capabilities data and correlate that data with the desired namespaces for the contact's client. The server MUST NOT send notifications related to any data formats that the contact's client has not asked for via the relevant "namespace+notify" disco#info feature. This enables a client to turn off all notifications (e.g., because of bandwidth restrictions) and to easily receive all desired data formats simply by adding support for the appropriate "namespace+notify" combination in its disco#info results and client capabililies. However, it also implies that a client can request notifications only on a global basis and cannot request, say, mood information only from certain contacts in the user's roster. Community consensus is that this is an acceptable tradeoff. Also, note that this works only if the account owner has a presence subscription to the contact and the contact has a presence subscription to the account owner.

Some examples may help to illustrate the concept of notification filtering. Here we show presence generated by two of the contacts listed above (benvolio@montague.net does have any presence subscriptions to or from juliet@capulet.com and therefore is not involved in these protocol flows).

]]>

We assume that Juliet's server doesn't know anything about these capabilities, so it sends service discovery information requests to each of the clients on Juliet's behalf (realistically, the capulet.com server will quickly build up a cache of client capabilities, with the result that it will not need to send these service discovery requests):

]]>

Note: The disco#info result from the node#ver includes only base protocol support, since user-configured notification preferences are to be specified in entity capability extensions. Therefore the server also needs to query the relevant extensions:

]]>

Note: As explained in XEP-0115, these requests would not all be sent to the same client and resource, but rather would be sent to random entities that advertise the same entity capabilities information.

The server shall also query the node#ver and node#ext combinations for other contacts (not shown here), which for <romeo@montague.net> indicate an interest in "http://jabber.org/protocol/geoloc+notify" and "http://jabber.org/protocol/tune+notify" but not "http://jabber.org/protocol/activity+notify".

Now we revisit account owner publication and server generation of notifications, with filtering enabled because the server has caps information:

  • If Juliet publishes a tune item to the presence-access "http://jabber.org/protocol/tune" node, her server will send notifications to <nurse@capulet.com/chamber> and <romeo@montague.net/orchard> (full JIDs).

  • If Juliet publishes an activity item to the presence-access "http://jabber.org/protocol/activity" node, her server will send notifications only to <nurse@capulet.com/chamber>.

  • If Juliet publishes a geolocation item to the roster-access "http://jabber.org/protocol/geoloc" node, her server will send notifications only to <romeo@montague.net/orchard>.

  1. The server MUST set the 'from' address on the notification to the bare JID (&BAREJID;) of the account owner (in these examples, "juliet@capulet.com").

  2. Any errors generated by the recipient or the recipient's server in relation to the notification MUST be directed to the JID of the 'from' address on the notification (i.e., the bare JID) so that bounce processing can be handled by the PEP service rather than by the publishing client.

  3. When sending notifications to an entity that has a presence subscription to the account owner, the server SHOULD include an &xep0033; "replyto" extension specifying the publishing resource (in this example, "juliet@capulet.com/balcony"); this enables the subscriber's client to differentiate between information received from each of the account owner's resources (for example, different resources may be in different places and therefore may need to specify distinct geolocation data). However, a server MUST NOT include the "replyto" address when sending a notification to an entity that does not have a presence subscription to the account owner.

  4. If the PEP service has presence information about the intended recipient, it SHOULD direct the notification(s) to the full JID(s) of the recipients (&FULLJID;); if the PEP service does not have presence information about a subscriber, it MUST address the notification to the subscriber's bare JID (&BAREJID;).

  1. If a subscriber subscribed using a full JID (&FULLJID;), domain identifier (&DOMAIN;), or domain plus resource (&DOMAINRES;), a PEP service MUST send one notification only, addressed to the subscribed JID.

  2. If a subscriber subscribed using a bare JID (&BAREJID;) and a PEP service does not have appropriate presence information about the subscriber, a PEP service MUST send at most one notification, addressed to the bare JID (&BAREJID;) of the subscriber, and MAY choose not to send any notification. (By "appropriate presence information" is meant an available presence stanza with non-negative priority and XEP-0115 data that indicates interest in the relevant data format.)

  3. If a subscriber subscribed using a bare JID (&BAREJID;) and a PEP service has appropriate presence information about the subscriber, the PEP service MUST send one notification to the full JID (&FULLJID;) of each of the subscriber's available resources that have specified non-negative presence priority and included XEP-0115 information that indicates an interest in the data format.

  1. When an account owner publishes an item to a node, a PEP service MUST generate a notification and send it to all appropriate subscribers (where the number of notifications is determined by the foregoing rules).

  2. When a PEP service receives initial presence information from a subscriber's resource with a non-negative priority and including XEP-0115 information that indicates an interest in the data format, it MUST generate a notification containing the last published item for that node and send it to the newly-available resource.

  3. As an exception to the foregoing MUST rules, a PEP service MUST NOT send notifications to a subscriber if the user has blocked the subscriber from receiving all or any kinds of stanza (presence, message, IQ, or any combination thereof) using communiations blocking as specified in XMPP IM.

As mentioned, a PEP service MUST send the last published item to all new subscribers and to all newly-available resources for each subscriber. That is, the default value of the "pubsub#send_last_published_item" node configuration field must be "on_sub_and_presence"; this behavior essentially mimics the functionality of presence as defined in XMPP IM.

]]> ]]> Gerald Finzi Introduction (Allegro vigoroso) Music for "Love's Labors Lost" (Suite for small orchestra) 1 255 ]]>

A PEP service MUST:

A PEP service MAY support other use cases, affiliations, access models, and features, but such support is OPTIONAL.

Naturally, before an account owner attempts to complete any PEP use cases, its client SHOULD determine whether the account owner's server supports PEP; to do so, it MUST send a &xep0030; information request to the server:

]]>

If a server supports PEP, it MUST return an identity of "pubsub/pep" (as well as a list of the namespaces and other features it supports, including all supported XEP-0060 features):

... ]]>

A contact MAY send service discovery requests to the account owner's bare JID (&BAREJID;). If the contact already has a subscription to the account owner's presence, this is not necessary in order to receive notifications from the account owner via personal eventing. However, a user without a presence subscription needs to do so in order to discover if the account owner is a virtual pubsub service and to discover the account owner's eventing nodes. The relevant protocol flows are demonstrated in XEP-0060.

Note: When returning disco#info results, the account owner's server MUST check the access model for each of the account owner's PEP nodes and MUST return as service discovery items only those nodes to which the contact is allowed to subscribe or from which the contact is allowed to retrieve items without first subscribing.

This subset of Publish-Subscribe defines and registers two additional pubsub features, as shown in the following table.

Note: The feature names are of the form "http://jabber.org/protocol/pubsub#name", where "name" is the text specified in the first column below.

Name Description Support
auto-create The service supports auto-creation of nodes on publish to a non-existent node. REQUIRED for PEP services, OPTIONAL for generic pubsub services
publish-and-configure The service supports specification of desired node configuration on publish. REQUIRED for PEP services, OPTIONAL for generic pubsub services

In order to ensure appropriate access to information published at nodes of type "presence" and "roster", a PEP service MUST re-calculate access controls when:

  1. A presence subscription state changes (e.g., when a subscription request is approved).
  2. A roster item is modified (e.g., when the item is moved to a new roster group).

If the modification results in a loss of access, the service MUST cancel the entity's subscription. In addition, the service MAY send a message to the (former) subscriber informing it of the cancellation (for information about the format of messages sent to notify subscribers of subscription cancellation, see the "Notification of Subscription Denial or Cancellation" section of XEP-0060).

A PEP node with an access model of "whitelist" and no entities on the whitelist effectively results in a node that enables private data storage, e.g. as defined in &xep0049;. A separate document will specify private data storage via PEP in more detail.

A PEP service MAY enforce additional privacy and security policies when determining whether an entity is allowed to subscribe to a node or retrieve items from a node; however, any such policies shall be considered specific to an implementation or deployment and are out of scope for this document.

This document requires no interaction with &IANA;.

The ®ISTRAR; includes a category of "pubsub" in its registry of Service Discovery identities (see &DISCOCATEGORIES;); as a result of this document, the Registrar includes a type of "pep" to that category.

The registry submission is as follows:

pubsub pep A personal eventing service that supports the publish-subscribe subset defined in XEP-0163. XEP-0163 ]]>

The XMPP Registrar maintains a registry of service discovery features (see &DISCOFEATURES;), which includes a number of features that may be returned by pubsub services. The following registry submission has been provided to the XMPP Registrar for that purpose.

http://jabber.org/protocol/pubsub#auto-create The service supports automatic creation of nodes on publish. XEP-0163 http://jabber.org/protocol/pubsub#publish-and-configure The service accepts node configuration forms on publish. XEP-0163 ]]>

Because Personal Eventing via Pubsub simply reuses the protocol specified in XEP-0060, a separate schema is not needed.

The authors wish to thank the participants in the XMPP Interoperability Testing Event held July 24 and 25, 2006, who provided valuable feedback that resulted in radical simplification of the protocol.

Thanks also to the many members of the standards@xmpp.org discussion list who patiently suffered through seemingly endless discussion of the auto-create and publish-and-configure features.