delayed easy handle kill caused double Curl_close() call

Hauke Duden provided an example program that made the multi
interface crash.  His example simply used the multi interface and
did first one FTP transfer and after completion it used a second
easy handle and did another FTP transfer on the same FTP server.

This triggered a bug in the "delayed easy handle kill" system
that curl uses: when an FTP connection is left alive it must keep
an easy handle around internally - only for the purpose of having
an easy handle when it later disconnects it. The code assumed
that when the easy handle was removed and an internal reference
was made, that version could be killed later on when a new easy
handle came using the same connection. This was wrong as Hauke's
example showed that the removed handle wasn't killed for real
until later. This caused a double close attempt => segfault.
This commit is contained in:
Daniel Stenberg 2010-03-23 13:18:30 +01:00
parent b33ddd615a
commit 2a94293efd
3 changed files with 25 additions and 3 deletions

15
CHANGES
View File

@ -6,6 +6,21 @@
Changelog
Daniel Stenberg (23 Mar 2010)
- Hauke Duden provided an example program that made the multi interface crash.
His example simply used the multi interface and did first one FTP transfer
and after completion it used a second easy handle and did another FTP
transfer on the same FTP server.
This triggered a bug in the "delayed easy handle kill" system that curl
uses: when an FTP connection is left alive it must keep an easy handle
around internally - only for the purpose of having an easy handle when it
later disconnects it. The code assumed that when the easy handle was removed
and an internal reference was made, that version could be killed later on
when a new easy handle came using the same connection. This was wrong as
Hauke's example showed that the removed handle wasn't killed for real until
later. This caused a double close attempt => segfault.
Daniel Stenberg (22 Mar 2010)
- Thomas Lopatic fixed the alarm()-based DNS timeout:

View File

@ -36,6 +36,7 @@ This release includes the following bugfixes:
o TFTP fixed TSIZE handling for uploads
o SSL possible double free when reusing curl handle
o alarm()-based DNS timeout bug
o re-used FTP connection multi interface crash
This release includes the following known bugs:
@ -47,6 +48,6 @@ advice from friends like these:
Steven M. Schweda, Yang Tse, Jack Zhang, Tom Donovan, Martin Hager,
Daniel Fandrich, Patrick Monnerat, Pat Ray, Wesley Miaw, Ben Greear,
Ryan Chan, Markus Duft, Andrei Benea, Jacob Moshenko, Daniel Johnson,
Constantine Sapuntzakis, Douglas Steinwand, Thomas Lopatic
Constantine Sapuntzakis, Douglas Steinwand, Thomas Lopatic, Hauke Duden
Thanks! (and sorry if I forgot to mention someone)

View File

@ -2416,10 +2416,16 @@ static CURLMcode add_closure(struct Curl_multi *multi,
if(!inuse) {
/* cl->easy_handle is now killable */
infof(data, "Delayed kill of easy handle %p\n", cl->easy_handle);
/* unmark it as not having a connection around that uses it anymore */
cl->easy_handle->state.shared_conn= NULL;
Curl_close(cl->easy_handle);
if(cl->easy_handle->state.closed) {
infof(data, "Delayed kill of easy handle %p\n", cl->easy_handle);
/* close handle only if curl_easy_cleanup() already has been called
for this easy handle */
Curl_close(cl->easy_handle);
}
if(p)
p->next = n;
else