diff --git a/sickbeard/tv.py b/sickbeard/tv.py
index 82e2c536..5466712a 100644
--- a/sickbeard/tv.py
+++ b/sickbeard/tv.py
@@ -1276,8 +1276,9 @@ class TVShow(object):
             if epStatus == DOWNLOADED and curQuality == Quality.UNKNOWN:
                 return Overview.QUAL
             elif epStatus in (SNATCHED, SNATCHED_PROPER, SNATCHED_BEST):
+                if curQuality < maxBestQuality:
+                    return Overview.QUAL
                 return Overview.SNATCHED
-            # if they don't want re-downloads then we call it good if they have anything
             elif maxBestQuality == None:
                 return Overview.GOOD
             # if they have one but it's not the best they want then mark it as qual